Hotel Reviews | Hotel Ratings | Resort Reviews | TravelPost.com
Home > New York Hotels > The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel > Hotel Review from Hamishes

The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel

4 Stars
This Review
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel photo

Get rates
35 East 76th Street (Upper East Side)   [edit info]
New York, NY 10075, United States +1 212 744 1600 www.thecarlyle.com - see rates
Check-in time: 3:00p    Check-out time: 1:00p
map of hotel
A timeless classic, The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel, has been called home by leaders in world affairs, business, society entertainment and... more »
 
Write a Hotel Review  Facebook   Twitter
 
 

Hotel Review

1 of 13 reviews
 
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful
Dreadfully overrated – Posted Dec 20, 2006
by Hamishes  (1 reviews)
   
         
Horrible
57 year old with a luxury budget, traveling for leisure

As of December 2006, the hotel is undergoing reconstruction, a fact conveniently omitted when we booked the room directly with the hotel.

We awoke the first morning to jack-hammers and electric drills in the room above ours. We were then moved to a 'quieter' room, this one had jack-hammers and drills in the adjacent room. Aside from the inexcusable omission about the construction, the overall service at this 'classic' is simply not worth the $600+ price.

The shower stall wasn't sealed, resulting in the tiny bathroom flooding with each shower. The Kiehl amenities were missing until we begged the staff for them. Later, we discovered that the staff tops up partially used Kiehl bottles with tap water, rather than replacing them with new ones! The robes in the room were tattered and had to be replaced. The internet connector cable was broken and had to be replaced. The concierge's telephone line is always busy.

The doormen are usually MIA, so you get to hail your own taxi (you can tell when they are on duty - they turn on the outside overhead heaters, an amenity not provided to mere guests!) The room service is dreadfully slow (plan at least an hour for food to arrive). And the final straw came when the staff moved us to the new 'quieter' room: Whoever moved our luggage, reached inside and took the box of complimentary chocolates originally provided by the hotel!

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
Sign in to leave comments
 
ads
 
ads

New York Hotel Deals

About TravelPost  |   Help  |   Contact TravelPost  |   Privacy Policy  |   Terms of Service  

  Top United States Travel Destinations  |   Travel Blogs  |   Cheap Airline Tickets - Kayak  

this is where check rates will go