Hotel Reviews | Hotel Ratings | Resort Reviews | TravelPost.com
Home > New York Hotels > The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel - Reviews

The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel

4 Stars
 
Reviews
Map
Photos
Rates
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel photo

Get rates
35 East 76th Street (Upper East Side)   [edit info]
New York, NY 10075, United States +1 212 744 1600 www.thecarlyle.com - see rates
Check-in time: 3:00p    Check-out time: 1:00p
map of hotel
A timeless classic, The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel, has been called home by leaders in world affairs, business, society entertainment and... more »
 
Write a Hotel Review  Facebook   Twitter
 
 
average guest rating 4.1 out of 5

Hotel Reviews

Review Filters
User Rating
Trip Purpose
  •   leisure
  •   business
  •   other
  •   show all
Budget
Age
Gender
Source
 
Sort by:   newest   best   worst 1-10 of 13 reviews

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful
laxualy accomodation and located cent... – Posted Apr 07, 2009
by TravelerJapan  (22 reviews)
 
         
Excellent
35 year old with a moderate budget, traveling for leisure

this is laxualy accomodation and located central NYC. the hotel is very good to launch your great vacation.

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
Great Location ..Luxurious I recomm... – Posted Apr 06, 2009
by MCGal  (32 reviews)
 
         
Excellent
47 year old with a luxury budget, traveling for leisure

Pure heaven. Huge room, so very comfortable, so well-appointed. Kiehl products in the bath

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
Like home – Posted Feb 28, 2007
by ElenaBostonTraveler  (1 reviews)
 
         
Excellent
52 year old female with a luxury budget, traveling for business

Even if it's been some time since you were a guest, you are never forgotten at The Carlyle. There are lovely rooms, plush amenities, courteous staff, the best location in Manhattan. I’ve been staying there since the early '80s and it only gets better each time I stay. It's luscious!

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful
Dreadfully overrated – Posted Dec 20, 2006
by Hamishes  (1 reviews)
   
         
Horrible
57 year old male with a luxury budget, traveling for leisure

As of December 2006, the hotel is undergoing reconstruction, a fact conveniently omitted when we booked the room directly with the hotel.

We awoke the first morning to jack-hammers and electric drills in the room above ours. We were then moved to a 'quieter' room, this one had jack-hammers and drills in the adjacent room. Aside from the inexcusable omission about the construction, the overall service at this 'classic' is simply not worth the $600+ price.

The shower stall wasn't sealed, resulting in the tiny bathroom flooding with each shower. The Kiehl amenities were missing until we begged the staff for them. Later, we discovered that the staff tops up partially used Kiehl bottles with tap water, rather than replacing them with new ones! The robes in the room were tattered and had to be replaced. The internet connector cable was broken and had to be replaced. The concierge's telephone line is always busy.

The doormen are usually MIA, so you get to hail your own taxi (you can tell when they are on duty - they turn on the outside overhead heaters, an amenity not provided to mere guests!) The room service is dreadfully slow (plan at least an hour for food to arrive). And the final straw came when the staff moved us to the new 'quieter' room: Whoever moved our luggage, reached inside and took the box of complimentary chocolates originally provided by the hotel!

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
Like the finest cashmere – Posted Nov 28, 2006
by sunnyflies  (3 reviews)
 
         
Excellent
57 year old female with a luxury budget, traveling for leisure

It was very comfortable, luxurious, and well located. There is nothing like the real thing. Too many hotels are rated five star when they do not deserve it, this one does. I loved the heated marble floors in one suite I had, not all have them, and the beds are fabulous with their top flight linens. The best shopping NYC has to offer is right outside its door and so is a wonderful very New York luncheonette. The hotel is very discreet and one can never tell who is also staying there unless the paparazzi gives them away.

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
excellent hotel – Posted Nov 18, 2006
 
         
Excellent

Fabulous Madison Avenue location in the midst of world class shopping - or window shopping - with extraordinarily comfortable and luxurious rooms. I loved the heated marble floor in one bathroom I had and the drenching rain shower was so nice I...

read full hotel review on Yahoo! Travel

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
the best and most wonderful place to – Posted Aug 05, 2006
 
         
Excellent

the best and most wonderful place to stay to celebrate something special,ie. (anniversary).....food was great...servvice spectacular....not the place to go fi you are looking for a deal...this is all about class and a special...

read full hotel review on IgoUgo.com

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
not worth the hype – Posted Jan 01, 2006
   
         
Horrible

We saw a Steve Tyrell performance in the Cafe Carlyle and really enjoyed the performance. Steve has an excellent stage personality and quality voice. His approach to the music was caring and we would recommend any music lover to see him but not at...

read full hotel review on Yahoo! Travel

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
Good taste and timeless class – Posted Jun 17, 2005
by cefe
 
         
Excellent

pros: service, decor, barMy family visits the Carlyle each year and we always enjoy our stay. The suites are spacious and tastefully decorated. The service in exceptional, and the views of the park are a welcome perk. It is a convenient location...

read full hotel review on Citysearch

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
I took my wife to the Carlyle for her – Posted Jun 07, 2005
by sabine_farm
 
         
Excellent

I took my wife to the Carlyle for her 35th birthday. The staff did an amazing job making us feel special. The food was wonderful, drinks in Bemelman's were wonderful, when you turn on the hurricane strength shower, you get hot water immediately, I...

read full hotel review on Citysearch

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
 
ads
 
$580-$926
Get Rates for
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
 
Set check-in date   
 
Set check-out date
 
Check on Kayak.com  (search 100+ sites)
 
 
ads

New York Hotel Deals

Other Hotels Similar to The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel

PriceNameStarsAmenitiesRatingDistance **
$468-$827 The Michelangelo Hotel No Airport Shuttle No Casino Fitness Room No Golf Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool Restaurant No Spa 4.3 / 5 1.33 mi
$452-$686 Royalton No Airport Shuttle No Casino Fitness Room No Golf Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool Restaurant Spa 4.0 / 5 1.63 mi
$430-$648 W New York - The Tuscany No Airport Shuttle No Casino Fitness Room No Golf Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Not Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool No Restaurant No Spa 4.0 / 5 1.87 mi
$493-$763 The Muse New York - a Kimpton Hotel No Airport Shuttle No Casino Fitness Room No Golf Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool Restaurant No Spa 4.4 / 5 1.52 mi
$396-$508 Fitzpatrick Grand Central No Airport Shuttle No Casino No Fitness Room No Golf No Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Not Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool Restaurant No Spa 4.2 / 5 1.57 mi
$452-$686 Royalton No Airport Shuttle No Casino Fitness Room No Golf Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool Restaurant Spa 4.0 / 5 1.63 mi
$416-$487 Lombardy Hotel No Airport Shuttle No Casino Fitness Room No Golf Internet Access Kitchenette Parking Not Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool Restaurant No Spa 3.7 / 5 1.01 mi
$430-$648 W New York - The Tuscany No Airport Shuttle No Casino Fitness Room No Golf Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Not Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool No Restaurant No Spa 4.0 / 5 1.87 mi
$396-$508 Fitzpatrick Grand Central No Airport Shuttle No Casino No Fitness Room No Golf No Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Not Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool Restaurant No Spa 4.2 / 5 1.57 mi
$477-$655 Fitzpatrick Manhattan No Airport Shuttle No Casino No Fitness Room No Golf No Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Not Pet Friendly Swimming Pool Restaurant No Spa 3.9 / 5 1.00 mi
** distance from The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel

Top Rated Hotels in New York, NY

  1. Jet Luxury Resorts @ St. Regis, New York
  2. The Michelangelo Hotel
  3. Harlem Flophouse
  4. Royalton
  5. Lombardy Hotel
  6. W New York - The Tuscany
  7. The Muse New York - a Kimpton Hotel
  8. The Maritime Hotel
  9. Fitzpatrick Grand Central
  10. Fitzpatrick Manhattan
  11. Millenium Hilton
  12. Trump International Hotel & Tower
  13. Omni Berkshire Place
  14. Courtyard New York Manhattan/Upper East Side
  15. The Franklin
  16. Comfort Inn
  17. Grand Hyatt New York
  18. Manhattan Broadway Hotel
  19. Gershwin Hotel
  20. The Waldorf Astoria
  21. Millennium UN Plaza Hotel NY
  22. Hotel Plaza Athenee
  23. Warwick Hotel New York
  24. Westin New York at Times Square
  25. Manhattan Club
  1. The Time Hotel
  2. Renaissance New York Hotel Times Square
  3. Sofitel New York
  4. The 414 Inn Hotel
  5. Washington Square Hotel
  6. Hotel Elysee
  7. Dylan Hotel
  8. W New York - Union Square
  9. Imperial Court
  10. The Shoreham Hotel
  11. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
  12. Kitano Hotel
  13. Hotel On Rivington
  14. New York Marriott Downtown
  15. The Carlton
  16. Morgans, A Morgans Original
  17. The Michelangelo Hotel Corporate Apts
  18. Wingate by Wyndham Manhattan Midtown
  19. Hotel Mela
  20. The Ritz-Carlton New York, Central Park
  21. Doubletree Metropolitan Hotel New York City
  22. Bridgestreet Ellington
  23. Churchill Residence Suites Midtown
  24. The Pod Hotel New York
  25. Hilton Manhattan East

About TravelPost  |   Help  |   Contact TravelPost  |   Privacy Policy  |   Terms of Service  

  Top United States Travel Destinations  |   Travel Blogs  |   Cheap Airline Tickets - Kayak  

this is where check rates will go