Loved - The pools, although not heated very well during chilly November weather as promised / The room quality (decor) / The relaxing and beautiful location of the property (harbor, views, etc...) / the overall indoor appearance of the hotel
Merely ok - the restaurant choices could have been better, as the only restaurant with truly good food was the steakhouse which is exorbitant in price, so not a very good option for daily meals if trying to stay on a reasonable budget / the customer service was not always "preferred" in level / cleanliness of the night table which hadn't been wiped off, along with a few hairs in our sheets, and the lobby bathroom could have been much better
Poor - the beds were comfortable if you were Fred Flinstone and wanted to sleep on a slab of rock...definitely not up to "preferred" standards / the lack of a shuttle to the islands / the promise of Kid Care when traveling as a single mother who therefore could not use the spa the entire time since Kid Care had been canceled, but not updated on the website to let travelers know this when booking / the snippiness of the guy in the towel hut who had to work on Thanksgiving and was not so nice when he informed me that the towels may not be available after 2:30 p.m. since he was closing up, and after all, it "...is thanksgiving." If you work in hospitality, unfortunately some of you get stuck working on holidays, and that is what the hotel is in business for! I used to work in the industry myself, and if you don't like it, then change jobs! Also, the snippiness of those in the spa on the one day I managed to go in for a massage (except the masseuse who was very pleasant.) And lastly, the BUG BITES!!!!! I know it may not be the hotel's fault, but what about screens on the balcony doors? And maybe you could spray the property to reduce infestations?
Overall, "Preferred" needs to re-evaluate their classification of this property for sure!