Robert Treat Hotel

We were looking for a clean, convenient, safe location to stay for a reasonable price while visiting the Big Apple. The hotel offers shuttle service to and from Newark Airport and Penn Station Newark (just a few blocks away) that takes you directly into Penn Station NY in 20 minutes. Rooms were large, comfortable and quiet. We were definitely return to this hotel.

I realize that we are on that Newark is on the east coast, but for 100 bucks I ought to get something good in Newark! I had to stay there, like lots of other people, because of the bar exam. Basically, the elevators didn't work and there was no apology or even a stairway that went all the way to the ground floor. They also own the building next door, so you had to use those elevators half the time, but one can only walk through to the hotel from some floors, contrary to what they told me there is no wireless internet in the rooms, the cable had bad reception. On top of everything else, the restaurant was mediocre and overpriced. The staff at the front desk pretty much acted like it wasn't there problem that the elevators were broken. The service at this place is more comparable to eastern Europe than anyplace in the US or western Europe. I was very disappointed.

My company booked this hotel for me so I'm not sure about the price I stayed at but I checked the average prices online and it is not that bad. I loved my stay here. The people were all very friendly and the furniture and rooms were great. It all looked pretty new and was definitely very clean. I did not try out any of the amenities because it was just a business trip so I am not sure whether there are pools and etc or if they are good so you might need to research that on your own if that is important to you. I had a great stay here and I hope you will too.