The best part about the Night hotel is the location - it's about 1/2 block from the heart of Times Square, so is great for business, shopping and pretty much anything in the City.
I also appreciated the Night Hotel's styling details. It definitely tried very hard to convey an ultra-chic sensibility with black and white photos of models on the walls, a huge black door entrance, no outside signage, and the coolest room number indicators I've ever seen (small LCD TV screens with an animated number - see my photo of this.) With the futuristic decor, at times, I felt like I was in Blade Runner, which, actually, was pretty cool!
But did it oversell me on the style and vibe at the hotel? To be sure, there were no tattooed or pierced model-types in the lobby (as shown on the website), and the lobby and bar were empty every time I came and went from my room (though to be honest, I was there on a Sunday and Monday night and the weather wasn't particularly good.) Maybe I just hit an off night, or maybe it's just too small of a hotel to be a "scene" in its own right.
One issue that needs to be resolved is the check-in process. I prepaid for a queen size room (I'm a tall guy so this is important to me), but they didn't have one available at check-in, so were going to put me into the penthouse. That would have been great, but the computer wouldn't let me upgrade, so I ended up in a small full size bed, knowing the whole night that the penthouse upstairs was empty.
The next night, my queen size bed room far more spacious and comfortable. There are some great design and amenity touches in the room, such as fluorescent lighting UNDER the bed, a 40 inch flat panel TV, and an open-air shower. I would have expected more than the rather pedestrian soaps and shampoos for such as styled hotel, but the towels were fantastic - probably the softest hotel towels I've ever used.
At $250 per night before taxes, this was a good deal for mid-week NYC hotel stay.
Would I stay here again? Maybe, but I'd look at some of the other boutique options first, though I wouldn't be unhappy staying here again.