Compare Prices and Availability for Montauk Hotels on Travelsearch.com
Browse Montauk Hotels and Unbiased Traveler Reviews
- Recent Low Price$399
- Gurneys Inn Resort and Spa
290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY
map
(2.8 mi. away)
105 rooms, renovated 11 years ago
    
Amazing
9.2/10
2 reviews
#1 out of 20 Hotels in Montauk based on all traveler reviews
- "Gurneys has best beach on Long Island ..."
- "I love the..."
Read all reviews
- Recent Low Price$125
- Ocean Beach Resort
S Emerson Ave, Montauk, NY
map
(0.6 mi. away)
80 rooms
  
Amazing
9.0/10
1 review
#2 out of 20 Hotels in Montauk based on all traveler reviews
- "love it every year!!!! - My husband and 2 young..."
Read all reviews
- Recent Low Price$100
- Ruschmeyer's Hotel and Motel
Second House Rd, Montauk, NY
map
(0.6 mi. away)
20 rooms, 1 floor, renovated 22 years ago
Amazing
9.0/10
1 review
#3 out of 20 Hotels in Montauk based on all traveler reviews
- "The new ruscmeyer's - As a child i'd regularly..."
Read all reviews
- Recent Low Price$74
- Harborside Motel
W Lake Dr, Montauk, NY
map
(0.6 mi. away)
27 rooms, 2 floors, renovated 4 years ago
Great
7.0/10
1 review
#4 out of 20 Hotels in Montauk based on all traveler reviews
- "Pleasant suprise - My husband and I decided..."
Read all reviews
- Recent Low Price$99
- Montauk Manor
236 Edgemere St, Montauk, NY
map
(0.6 mi. away)
140 rooms, 4 floors, renovated 21 years ago
Good
6.2/10
1 review
#5 out of 20 Hotels in Montauk based on all traveler reviews
- "It's a lovely hotel with many beautiful and..."
Read all reviews
- Recent Low Price$75
- Royal Atlantic Beach Resort
126 South Edgemere St, Montauk, NY
map
(0.6 mi. away)
151 rooms, 2 floors, renovated 7 years ago
Mediocre
4.0/10
2 reviews
#6 out of 20 Hotels in Montauk based on all traveler reviews
- "A ROYAL DUMP - I was at the Royal..."
- "Best hotel location in Montauk!..."
Read all reviews
- Recent Low Price$205
- Atlantic Terrace
21 Surfside Place, Montauk, NY
map
(1.2 mi. away)
100 rooms, 2 floors, renovated 22 years ago
Mediocre
4.0/10
3 reviews
#7 out of 20 Hotels in Montauk based on all traveler reviews
- "It was a good location and had a friendly staff,..."
- "Worst experience ever! - My husband and I were..."
Read all reviews
- Recent Low Price$75
- Oceanside Beach Resort
626 Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY
map
(0.6 mi. away)
30 rooms, 2 floors, renovated 4 years ago
Poor
3.0/10
1 review
#8 out of 20 Hotels in Montauk based on all traveler reviews
- "Watch out - My group has a terrible..."
Read all reviews
-
- Lido Resort
5 South Emery Street, Montauk, NY
Awful
2.0/10
1 review
#9 out of 20 Hotels in Montauk based on all traveler reviews
- "Montauk's Dumpiest Motel - This motel seemed fine..."
Read all reviews
- Recent Low Price$149
- Montauk Yacht Club Resort and Marina
32 Star Island Rd, Montauk, NY
map
(2.4 mi. away)
107 rooms, 2 floors, renovated 2 years ago
Stay Away
1.8/10
1 review
#10 out of 20 Hotels in Montauk based on all traveler reviews
- "Very disappointed - My husband and I took a..."
Read all reviews
Are we missing a Montauk hotel? Add a new hotel
Hotels in Other Popular Cities
|
|