When you write a review for a hotel, you have to consider what you were looking for.
We wanted a hotel within walking distance of Six Flags Over Georgia. Our requirements were good rates, clean rooms, a pool to use in the off-time. We read the previous reviews, but the rate was significantly lower than the neighbors, so we took a chance.
We were met with an extremely friendly and helpful staff - who allowed us to check-in earlier than we were supposed to and even helped us with our luggage -who kept the rooms clean and in working order - who cleaned the pool both of the days we were there. The room wasn't brand new, but the beds were good, the bathroom was clean and working, we had a mini-fridge, coffee pot, hair dryer and a microwave in the room and thankfully, the a/c kept us ice-cold.
Important to us: The pool was open later than Six Flags so the kids could cool off prior to bed and earlier than check-out so they could swim before we left.
If you want to stay in the newest rooms, then pay the extra $40plus/night and go to the neighboring hotels, but if you just want a nice clean place to stay that's within easy walking distance of the park, this was the right choice for us.