We've gone to this hotel for over 16 years when it was still the Windjammer. Every time we've gone there, we've been happy with our room and service. One time we tried to book a room with another hotel in the area, and it was a miserable experience.
This hotel made me feel important: They set up our room for my husband's birthday so it was decorated when we came in. There was a message in a bottle and some sparkling cider for us, also.