Hotel Reviews | Hotel Ratings | Resort Reviews | TravelPost.com
Home > New York Hotels > Algonquin Hotel - Reviews

Algonquin Hotel

4 Stars
 
Reviews
Map
Photos
Rates
Algonquin Hotel photo

Get rates
59 W 44th St (Theater District)   [edit info]
New York, NY 10036-6613, United States +1 212 840 6800 www.algonquinhotel.com - see rates
Check-in time: 3:00p    Check-out time: 12:00p
map of hotel
Located in the heart of Midtown Manhattan, the Algonquin is the hotel preferred by those who best appreciate New York. The Algonquin Hote... more »
 
Write a Hotel Review  Facebook   Twitter
 
 
average guest rating 4.4 out of 5

Hotel Reviews

Review Filters
User Rating
Trip Purpose
Budget
Age
Gender
Source
 
Sort by:   newest   best   worst 41-50 of 78 reviews

this is the best hotel we've stayed at – Posted Feb 07, 2007
 
         
Excellent

this is the best hotel we've stayed at in NYC. Lovely atmosphere, subways nearby, within walking distance to times square (3 blocks or so. far enough from all the noise). wonderful and friendly house cat.

...

read full hotel review on Epinions.com

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful
Stay away from the Algonquin – Posted Jan 27, 2007
by LantieQuinones  (1 reviews)
   
         
Horrible
34 year old female with a luxury budget, traveling for leisure

The Algonquin Hotel bills itself as the oldest operating hotel in New York City, and is surely appears that it is.

Firstly, they claimed on their website that they had done renovations to the hotel, which from what I could tell only including slapping up plasma TVs on the walls and calling it a day. The rooms are abominable-dirty furniture, 19th century plumbing and ancient, broken climate controls.

Secondly, the charm of this "luxury" hotel lies with the "Algonquin round table" where legendary authors gathered and talked literature. This "round table" room has possibly the most dreadful food I have experienced in New York. The French onion soup was burnt and the hamburger was raw.

Thirdly, the mystic of the hotel lies with its purported impeccable service. Well apparently, service involves a collection of untrained pseudo-adolescents who apparently have been mistaken for hotel management/workers. The young girl who greeted me on arrival couldn't find my reservation and then proceeded to ask me if I was actually at the right hotel. Considering I had arrived late (don't make that mistake, you will end up in one their unused rooms that they keep for emergencies, translate "unused" as dirty and in poor repair) and had called ahead to let the hotel know, I was very concerned that this smarmy prepubescent couldn't find my reservation.

Fourthly, when I called repeatedly (three times in one night) to report the complete disrepair of the air conditioning/climate control, I was told that this was my fault, apparently allowing guests to control their own climate control is unacceptable, and that the unit was frozen up and could not be repaired. Yet, this brought no rectification of the matter. I then attempted to open the windows in the room and was reprimanded by staff that this was not allowed.

I left as soon as I could and booked another hotel on the same street. Interestingly, after I submitted a dispute for the charges from the Algonquin to my credit card, the Algonquin Hotel offered me two free nights in one of their suites. My response, as the old saying goes, "I wouldn't stay there if they paid me".

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
4 friends stayed here in April 2006 as – Posted Jan 12, 2007
 
         
Excellent

4 friends stayed here in April 2006 as a rendevous before we all moved away from one another. our suite was perfect size for the 4 of us, rooms were clean and the staff treated us well. especially liked the friendly bellmen/doormen, they gave us...

read full hotel review on IgoUgo.com

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
Rooms are clean, comfortable and – Posted Dec 21, 2006
 
         
Excellent

Rooms are clean, comfortable and spacious for Manhattan. The staff is friendly and helpful. And the lobby is beautiful - takes you back to the heyday of the hotel, well preserved and a nice place to hang out for a drink.

read full hotel review on IgoUgo.com

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
A hidden gem – Posted Nov 29, 2006
by potterqueen
 
         
Excellent

pros: Comfortable, great location, caring staffWonderful hotel. My parents stay here when they visit. The location is amazing, the cozy, open lobby feels like the New York you expect. The cat is cute. The staff is always so helpful.

read full hotel review on Citysearch

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
this was our first vacation together in – Posted Oct 31, 2006
   
         
Good

this was our first vacation together in 10 years of our relationship. we came to see two broadway shows. the hotel was very nice and the stafff was uperb. however the rooms were so small and ridiculiously expensive. my other half sent for his...

read full hotel review on IgoUgo.com

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
Great location, friendly, helpful – Posted Oct 24, 2006
   
         
Good

Great location, friendly, helpful staff, clean rooms, great cleaing staff, loved the hotel cat Mathilda, highly recommended.

read full hotel review on IgoUgo.com

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
Hotel Review – – Posted Jun 17, 2006
   
         
Okay
by a traveler from East Lansing, MI
25 year old female with a moderate budget, traveling for leisure

The friendly staff made me feel comfortable.

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
Hotel Review – – Posted Jun 13, 2006
   
         
Mediocre
by a traveler from Sheboygan, WI
58 year old male with a luxury budget, traveling for leisure

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
If you are not wedded to five star – Posted Sep 13, 2006
 
         
Excellent

If you are not wedded to five star hotels with large rooms, The Algonquin is a gem of a hotel, full of character ambience and history. Dont miss the opportunity to walk down the hallways and read the Dorothy Parker quotes on the doors. Spend time...

read full hotel review on IgoUgo.com

Was this review helpful?   Yes   No Comment
 
ads
 
$498-$723
Get Rates for
Algonquin Hotel
 
Set check-in date   
 
Set check-out date
 
Check on Kayak.com  (search 100+ sites)
 
 
ads

New York Hotel Deals

Other Hotels Similar to Algonquin Hotel

PriceNameStarsAmenitiesRatingDistance **
$468-$827 The Michelangelo Hotel No Airport Shuttle No Casino Fitness Room No Golf Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool Restaurant No Spa 4.3 / 5 0.44 mi
$452-$686 Royalton No Airport Shuttle No Casino Fitness Room No Golf Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool Restaurant Spa 4.0 / 5 0.05 mi
$430-$648 W New York - The Tuscany No Airport Shuttle No Casino Fitness Room No Golf Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Not Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool No Restaurant No Spa 4.0 / 5 0.47 mi
$493-$763 The Muse New York - a Kimpton Hotel No Airport Shuttle No Casino Fitness Room No Golf Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool Restaurant No Spa 4.4 / 5 0.16 mi
$396-$508 Fitzpatrick Grand Central No Airport Shuttle No Casino No Fitness Room No Golf No Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Not Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool Restaurant No Spa 4.2 / 5 0.44 mi
$416-$487 Lombardy Hotel No Airport Shuttle No Casino Fitness Room No Golf Internet Access Kitchenette Parking Not Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool Restaurant No Spa 3.7 / 5 0.67 mi
$396-$508 Fitzpatrick Grand Central No Airport Shuttle No Casino No Fitness Room No Golf No Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Not Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool Restaurant No Spa 4.2 / 5 0.44 mi
$361-$566 Millenium Hilton No Airport Shuttle No Casino Fitness Room No Golf Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Not Pet Friendly Swimming Pool Restaurant Spa 4.2 / 5 3.39 mi
$332-$436 Courtyard New York Manhattan/Upper East Side No Airport Shuttle No Casino No Fitness Room No Golf Internet Access No Kitchenette Parking Not Pet Friendly Swimming Pool No Restaurant No Spa 3.0 / 5 2.53 mi
$302-$437 Comfort Inn No Airport Shuttle No Casino No Fitness Room No Golf Internet Access No Kitchenette No Parking Pet Friendly No Swimming Pool No Restaurant No Spa 3.5 / 5 0.51 mi
** distance from Algonquin Hotel

Top Rated Hotels in New York, NY

  1. Jet Luxury Resorts @ St. Regis, New York
  2. The Michelangelo Hotel
  3. Harlem Flophouse
  4. Royalton
  5. Lombardy Hotel
  6. W New York - The Tuscany
  7. The Muse New York - a Kimpton Hotel
  8. Fitzpatrick Grand Central
  9. The Maritime Hotel
  10. Fitzpatrick Manhattan
  11. Millenium Hilton
  12. Trump International Hotel & Tower
  13. Courtyard New York Manhattan/Upper East Side
  14. The Franklin
  15. Comfort Inn
  16. Omni Berkshire Place
  17. Grand Hyatt New York
  18. Manhattan Broadway Hotel
  19. Gershwin Hotel
  20. The Waldorf Astoria
  21. Millennium UN Plaza Hotel NY
  22. Hotel Plaza Athenee
  23. Warwick Hotel New York
  24. Westin New York at Times Square
  25. Manhattan Club
  1. The Time Hotel
  2. Sofitel New York
  3. Renaissance New York Hotel Times Square
  4. The 414 Inn Hotel
  5. Washington Square Hotel
  6. Hotel Elysee
  7. Dylan Hotel
  8. The Shoreham Hotel
  9. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
  10. Kitano Hotel
  11. W New York - Union Square
  12. Imperial Court
  13. Hotel On Rivington
  14. New York Marriott Downtown
  15. The Carlton
  16. Morgans, A Morgans Original
  17. The Michelangelo Hotel Corporate Apts
  18. Wingate by Wyndham Manhattan Midtown
  19. Hotel Mela
  20. The Ritz-Carlton New York, Central Park
  21. Churchill Residence Suites Midtown
  22. The Pod Hotel New York
  23. Hilton Manhattan East
  24. Doubletree Metropolitan Hotel New York City
  25. Bridgestreet Ellington

About TravelPost  |   Help  |   Contact TravelPost  |   Privacy Policy  |   Terms of Service  

  Top United States Travel Destinations  |   Travel Blogs  |   Cheap Airline Tickets - Kayak  

this is where check rates will go